We cannot do without it

Wednesday, 17 July, 2013 - 13:15

The expansion of offshore wind power capacity should be slowed according to the wishes of consumer protection groups. The industry, on the other hand, wishes to increase the speed. (Photo: Dong)

Offshore wind power is making household electricity expensive, warn consumer protection groups. Without offshore there will be no energy transition, says the offshore sector in response.

The German word “energiewende” has long been taken up internationally now, just as the word “kindergarten“ has. Three things are meant by the energiewende: firstly, stopping the use of fossil fuels that emit CO2 in the long term and the expansion of renewables; secondly, doing away with nuclear power; and thirdly, the setting up of “intelligent” grids and users.
At least this is what is widely understood by it amongst German politicians and public opinion. But obviously this cannot simply be assumed to be true globally. China, for example, does not speak of “renewable”, but of “CO2-free”. As a consequence, nuclear power there has the same status as wind and solar power.
Until now, offshore wind power had not been questioned as a pillar – maybe even the strongest one – of the energy transition in Germany. In the other countries bordering the North Sea the use of offshore winds has a similar importance, depending on the characteristics of the coast, although the energy transition concept does not involve as much ideology as in Germany. The UK, for example, is strongly supporting the offshore wind power sector to fulfil its self-commitment to climate protection.

Consumer protection groups want a slow-down
Although the expansion of offshore wind power in ­Germany has faced delays of several years, until recently nobody called it into question. This has now changed; offshore wind power is facing strong opposition. The heavy guns are not, as one might initially expect, being positioned by nature and animal protection campaigners, but by consumer protection groups. Especially the Federation of German Consumer Organisations (vzbv) has launched a high-calibre offensive which is certainly having an effect. But the vzbv will not be successful. When you look more closely at offshore turbines you see that they are an indispensible part of the energy transition.

You can read the complete article writen by Jörn Iken
in the latest issue of OFFSHORE WIND INDUSTRY.



You’ve really got to wonder. The Federation of ­German Consumer Organisations in the form of the Head of Construction, Energy and the ­Environment, Holger Krawinkel, swings its axe vigorously against wind and solar power in general and specifically against offshore wind power. Its criticism of the new energy sources can be summed up in three words: all too expensive. Well, obviously, for a lobbying group the lobby interest is the measure of ­all things.

Basically Krawinkel is demanding that we should largely do without the expensive energy sources of wind and solar power. But the big question mark: what, if not solar and wind power electricity, should take on supplying energy in the future, 600 TWh a year, after all? Why doesn’t the consumer advocate mention the development and handling costs of nuclear power? Why should there be no economies of scale just in offshore wind power, that is falling prices during the transition to large-scale production, when it is present throughout the whole of technical development history?

Not a word on all of this, but a finger pointed at the EEG levy. It is at the scale of one or two additional fill-ups at the petrol station, to think in terms of the fossil fuel age for a moment. It raises the suspicion that ideologically formed positions are dominant at the Federation of German ­Consumer Organisations and amongst its department heads. Nothing would be left of the energy transition if these forces had their way.

Jörn Iken

Similar Entries

The risk of a particular damage outcome for a specific transformer platform can only be established if the dynamics of the fire are analysed within the particular context of that prototype.

The risk of a particular damage outcome for a specific transformer platform can only be established if the dynamics of the fire are analysed within the particular context of that prototype. (Photo: Energinet.dk)

A transformer fire is one of two hazards, together with ship collision, in which the envisaged maximum damage potential is the total loss of an offshore transformer platform. The Danish TSO company, Energinet.dk, has enlisted the help of an international team of researchers and challenged them with lowering this risk.

The list of Dong Energy's suppliers in Germany

The list of Dong Energy's suppliers in Germany (Illustration: Dong Energy)

Offshore wind is good for a wide range of industries, including steel producers, component manufacturers and shipyards. According to a study by the German Federal Ministry of Economy and Energy, offshore wind technology has already created around 19,000 jobs in Germany. Large corporations as well as regional companies are benefiting.

Sea cable for alpha ventus

Delivery of the sea cable for the grid connection of alpha ventus – in other projects the cable connection has run less smoothly. (Photo: Offshore Wind Energy Association/E.ON Netz)

Many factors have contributed to the delays in the German offshore projects. One of these is the cable connection. Now it’s a case of making up for lost time.

The Xiangshui 200 MW offshore wind demonstration project has been approved by the National Development and Reform Commission,according to an article published by